← All Interactive Visuals · Healthcare & Policy ·Nov 14, 2026

Paying for readiness worked, until risk arrived

What happened when CMS paid small and rural ACOs to get ready for value-based care.

Paying for readiness worked, until risk arrived — What happened when CMS paid small and rural ACOs to get ready for value-based care.
Figure 3: ACO Investment Model net savings and gross spending reductions by performance year.

From 2016 to 2018, CMS advanced about $2 million each to small and rural ACOs. The model saved Medicare money every year, then most participants left when downside risk was required.

Key Strategic Takeaways

  • Upfront payments produced $381.5 million in net Medicare savings over 3 years.
  • 35 of 41 ACOs relied on outside management companies to run the work.
  • Most participants left after 2018, when the rules required downside risk.

About this visual

What happened when CMS paid small and rural ACOs to get ready for value-based care.

How to read this

Figure 3: ACO Investment Model net savings and gross spending reductions by performance year. Source: CMS Innovation Center, ACO Investment Model final evaluation, 2020

Related articles

Primary Data Source: CMS Innovation Center, ACO Investment Model final evaluation, 2020 · Author: Eli Brodsky

Related Analysis & Articles