← All Articles · Healthcare & RHTP ·Nov 14, 2026 ·8 min read

RHTP is at least the fifth attempt to fix rural health care. Here's what the first four bought.

By Eli Brodsky · Co-Lead · Healthcare Innovation, Technology & Strategy
RHTP is at least the fifth attempt to fix rural health care. Here's what the first four bought. — Healthcare & RHTP analysis graphic

I spent most of this year helping stand up a state Rural Health Transformation Program office in Louisiana, and I left that role last week. This piece is about the national program. Every state is moving fast right now, and almost nobody has time to ask a basic question: how has this been tried before, and what happened?

By my count, RHTP is at least the fifth federal attempt to stabilize rural health care in the last 30 years. Each earlier attempt bought something specific. Each one hit a wall. The evaluations are public, and they read like a checklist for what states should build into years 2 through 5.

Interactive Data Visual · Healthcare & Policy

Five attempts before RHTP, and what each one bought

Federal programs to stabilize rural health care since 1997, and where each one hit a wall.

Five attempts before RHTP, and what each one bought — Federal programs to stabilize rural health care since 1997, and where each one hit a wall.

RHTP is not the first federal effort to stabilize rural health care. This timeline shows 5 earlier programs, what each one bought, and where it stopped working. Select a bar for the detail.

  • Each earlier program bought one thing: survival, readiness, predictability or a floor.
  • Every wall appeared at the handoff, when the subsidy stopped growing or risk began.
  • RHTP awards end in 2030, so year 6 is the test.
Source: NBER working paper 35876; CMS Innovation Center evaluations of the ACO Investment Model, Pennsylvania Rural Health Model and CHART; UNC Sheps Center; CMS RHTP fact sheet Open Interactive Visual →

The start is better than most people expected

The early indicators are good.

  1. CMS approved all 50 states in December 2025, with first-year awards from $147 million to $281 million.
  2. States had until October 30, 2026 to obligate that money. Iowa announced it had obligated its full $209 million by early October. North Carolina obligated everything and published a public dashboard of every funded project, county and dollar amount. Others will publish the full breakdown before the end of the month.

Year 1 reports already public: Arkansas, Florida, Kansas, North Carolina and Texas. CMS has also posted what every state had obligated by July 31 and state scorecards drawn from the annual reports.

  1. All 50 states filed their first annual reports, and CMS announced $10 billion in Year 2 awards this month. That brings the total to $20 billion.
  2. Year 2 amounts barely moved. Half the states went up and half went down, and the largest increase was under 4%. CMS is rewarding progress at the margin without pulling the rug on anyone.

My state-by-state award analysis is at kamenpartners.net.

  1. KFF Health News collected more than half of the state progress reports and found states delivering on the federal technology priorities while still getting money to local communities.
Interactive Data Visual · Healthcare & Policy

Year 2 awards barely moved

State-by-state change in RHTP awards from Year 1 to Year 2.

Year 2 awards barely moved — State-by-state change in RHTP awards from Year 1 to Year 2.

CMS factored first-year progress into Year 2 awards, but the changes were small. Sort all 50 states by change or award size, and highlight any state.

  • 25 states gained and 25 lost, all within 4%.
  • About $68 million moved between states out of $10 billion.
  • 46 of 50 states changed by less than 3%.
Source: CMS RHTP award announcements, compiled by the National Rural Health Association, November 2026 Open Interactive Visual →

That is what the program asks for: CMS sets the frame, and each state fits it to its own hospitals, clinics, workforce and geography. It's working so far.

Two cautions. States had about 7 weeks to write applications and 10 months to obligate, so a lot of decisions were made at speed. And obligated money has only been committed. First-year funds have to be spent by September 30, 2027, and whether they bought anything lasting won't be known for years.

Which is why the earlier attempts matter.

Four attempts, four walls

AttemptYearsWhat it boughtWhere it hit the wall
Critical Access Hospital designation1997 to nowSurvival: margins up 3 to 4 points, fewer closuresScale: many hospitals shrank inpatient capacity, and independents still average 2.6% margins
ACO Investment Model2015 to 2018Readiness: about $2 million upfront per ACO, $381.5 million in net Medicare savingsRisk: most participants left when downside risk arrived
Pennsylvania Rural Health Model2019 to 2024Predictability: operating margins from -7.8% to -1.9% in year 1Design: mixed results overall, and year-end reconciliation kept budgets uncertain
Rural Emergency Hospital designation2023 to nowA floor: median margin from -17.9% to 7.4% across 32 early convertersScope: the hospital gives up inpatient care to get it

1. Critical Access Hospitals bought survival

Congress created the designation in 1997 and paid small rural hospitals based on their costs. A new NBER paper finds it raised operating margins 3 to 4 points and prevented some closures. It also pushed many more hospitals to downsize so they could qualify. Almost 30 years later, independent Critical Access Hospitals average a 2.6% operating margin against 7% for those owned by a health system, and they lose about 18 cents on every Medicaid dollar. The subsidy kept the doors open. It never gave these hospitals a business that works without it.

Interactive Data Visual · Healthcare & Policy

Every attempt moved the margin. None closed the gap. (Independence gap)

Rural hospital margins before and after two federal payment models, and the gap between independent and system-owned hospitals.

Every attempt moved the margin. None closed the gap. (Independence gap) — Interactive data visual on Healthcare & Policy

Global budgets in Pennsylvania and Rural Emergency Hospital conversion both lifted margins. Independent Critical Access Hospitals still earn less than half the margin of system-owned ones. Toggle between the 2 views.

  • Pennsylvania’s global budgets moved operating margins from -7.8% to -1.9% in year 1.
  • 32 early Rural Emergency Hospital converters went from a -17.9% to a 7.4% median total margin.
  • Independent Critical Access Hospitals average 2.6% margins against 7.0% for system-owned ones.
Source: Chatterjee, Coe and Werner, Health Affairs 2025; UNC Sheps Center, March 2026; Whaley, Bartlett and Bai, JAMA Health Forum 2024 Open Interactive Visual →

2. Upfront ACO payments bought readiness

From 2015 to 2018, CMS advanced about $2 million each to small and rural ACOs to pay for staff and infrastructure. It worked. The model saved Medicare a net $381.5 million with no drop in quality. Two details get forgotten. 35 of the 41 ACOs relied on outside management companies to run the work. And when the rules required them to take downside risk, most ended their participation, though many of their providers later joined other ACOs. Rural providers will do value-based care when someone pays for readiness. They leave when the only next step is a risk they can't absorb.

Interactive Data Visual · Healthcare & Policy

Paying for readiness worked, until risk arrived

What happened when CMS paid small and rural ACOs to get ready for value-based care.

Paying for readiness worked, until risk arrived — What happened when CMS paid small and rural ACOs to get ready for value-based care.

From 2016 to 2018, CMS advanced about $2 million each to small and rural ACOs. The model saved Medicare money every year, then most participants left when downside risk was required.

  • Upfront payments produced $381.5 million in net Medicare savings over 3 years.
  • 35 of 41 ACOs relied on outside management companies to run the work.
  • Most participants left after 2018, when the rules required downside risk.
Source: CMS Innovation Center, ACO Investment Model final evaluation, 2020 Open Interactive Visual →

3. Global budgets bought predictability

Pennsylvania gave 17 rural hospitals a fixed annual budget across payers from 2019 to 2024. Operating margins improved by up to 4 to 5 points against comparison hospitals, but the peer-reviewed evaluation called the results mixed, and CMS's own evaluators found the year-end reconciliation left hospitals unsure what they'd actually keep. Commercial payers doubted the model would last.

A sibling program, CHART, was announced in 2020 for 4 states. It ended in 2023 because no hospital signed a participation agreement. A Texas review pointed to a short window to decide and a 7-year commitment. Boards won't sign what they can't price.

4. Rural Emergency Hospitals bought a floor

Since 2023, a struggling hospital can drop inpatient beds and keep its emergency room and outpatient services with a federal subsidy. Early cost reports from 32 converters show median total margin moving from -17.9% to 7.4%, with the caveat that many reflect less than a full year. Researchers found the converters looked financially like the hospitals that closed. This one saves access by shrinking the hospital.

Interactive Data Visual · Healthcare & Policy

Every attempt moved the margin. None closed the gap.

Rural hospital margins before and after two federal payment models, and the gap between independent and system-owned hospitals.

Every attempt moved the margin. None closed the gap. — Interactive data visual on Healthcare & Policy

Global budgets in Pennsylvania and Rural Emergency Hospital conversion both lifted margins. Independent Critical Access Hospitals still earn less than half the margin of system-owned ones. Toggle between the 2 views.

  • Pennsylvania’s global budgets moved operating margins from -7.8% to -1.9% in year 1.
  • 32 early Rural Emergency Hospital converters went from a -17.9% to a 7.4% median total margin.
  • Independent Critical Access Hospitals average 2.6% margins against 7.0% for system-owned ones.
Source: Chatterjee, Coe and Werner, Health Affairs 2025; UNC Sheps Center, March 2026; Whaley, Bartlett and Bai, JAMA Health Forum 2024 Open Interactive Visual →

The pattern

  1. Money changed behavior every time. Rural providers responded quickly to each program.
  2. Each program bought one thing: survival, readiness, predictability or a floor. None bought a sustainable operating model.
  3. The wall always appeared at the handoff, when the subsidy stopped growing or the risk began.
  4. Design details decided outcomes more than the headline idea did.

RHTP is different in 2 ways that matter. It funds workforce, technology, payment models and facilities together, and it lets each state design around local conditions. It's the same in one way: the money ends. Year 5 is the handoff.

What RHTP has to do differently

  1. Name the year-6 payer in every award. If a funded service, license or position has no payer, shared service or operating budget lined up for 2031, it's a 5-year subsidy. That's what the first attempt was.
  2. Build the risk on-ramp before the readiness money runs out. The ACO model proved readiness can be bought. States should work with Medicaid and their managed care plans now on what providers step into next, sized so a small hospital can survive a bad year.
  3. Buy shared infrastructure once, and let providers govern it. Rural physicians trail urban ones on EHR adoption, 64% to 74%, and research shows a hospital's EHR choice shifts where its patients get referred. Data systems, analytics and EHR platforms are market structure decisions. If outside firms run everything, plan how the capability stays when they go.
  4. Aim technology where it can work. One study found about 946,000 rural residents who lack nearby care but already have adequate broadband. Another found the telehealth boom in mental health didn't bring specialists meaningfully more rural patients. Telehealth, remote monitoring and AI tools matter when they change who does the work and how it gets paid. State technology and innovation funds have almost no evaluated precedent, so the states running them should publish what they learn.
  5. Track the indicators the earlier attempts were judged on. Operating margins, the share of rural hospitals in the red (41.2% in 2025), the number at risk of closure (417), service lines kept, and rural participation in value-based contracts. One study found rural hospitals were 30% less likely to offer obstetrics 5 years after being acquired. If RHTP works, independence should get cheaper.
  6. Read the evaluations, then write your own. Every earlier program had an evaluator. RHTP states should publish results in plain numbers, the way North Carolina has started to, so the sixth attempt doesn't have to guess.

If you're building around RHTP

  1. Companies: show how your cost moves to a payer or a provider budget by year 6. A pilot that needs grant money forever is attempt 1 again.
  2. Consultants: the ACO model ran on outside managers. Leave capability behind when you go.
  3. Rural health organizations: you have leverage now that you didn't have in any earlier attempt. Use it to ask for price certainty and a governance seat.
  4. State staff: obligating the money was the first milestone. The next is being able to say what will still be running in 2031 and who pays for it.

I'm continuing this work at Kamen Partners, where I'll keep tracking these indicators across states. If you've lived through one of the earlier attempts, I'd like to hear what you'd tell the people running this one.

Sources

  1. KFF: A closer look at the $50 billion Rural Health Transformation Program
  2. CMS: Year 2 Rural Health Transformation awards
  3. NRHA: Year 1 and Year 2 award table
  4. Iowa HHS: first-year award fully obligated
  5. NCDHHS: RHTP dashboard
  6. KFF Health News on first-year progress reports
  7. McCarthy and Leinenbach, NBER w35876: effects of CAH designation
  8. Whaley, Bartlett and Bai, JAMA Health Forum 2024, summarized
  9. CMS: ACO Investment Model final evaluation
  10. Health Affairs Forefront: how rural ACOs responded to AIM
  11. Penn LDI: Pennsylvania Rural Health Model financial evaluation
  12. NORC: PARHM fourth annual evaluation
  13. CMS: CHART Model and Texas CHART review
  14. UNC Sheps: REH profitability before and after conversion and Did REH converters avoid closure
  15. Anzalone et al., BMC Health Services Research 2025: rural EHR adoption
  16. EHR vendor switching and patient sharing
  17. JAMA Health Forum broadband deserts study, summarized
  18. Telemedicine and rural mental health access, JAMA Network Open 2026, summarized
  19. Chartis rural hospital margins, via HFMA
  20. Dranove, Gaynor and Geddes, NBER w34159: rural acquisitions and maternal care
Continue Reading · Related Dispatches
Healthcare & RHTP · 7 min read

The patients are there. The specialists aren't.

Related Healthcare analysis: Of the 444 critical access and other rural hospitals in Texas, Louisiana, Mississippi, Alabama, Georgia, Florida and Arkansas, 380 a…

Healthcare & RHTP · 6 min read

RHTP Year 2: What Changed?

CMS's Year 2 RHTP awards kept every state within 4% of Year 1, but the money now follows execution: annual reports, policy follow-th…

Healthcare & RHTP · 5 min read

Food is Medicine Is in Most RHTP Plans. Few States Have Made It Medicine Yet.

About 20 states put food into their RHTP plans, but only Delaware, Virginia, Kansas and Arkansas have clinical designs that look str…

#RHTP #CMS #Healthcare