Every attempt moved the margin. None closed the gap.
Rural hospital margins before and after two federal payment models, and the gap between independent and system-owned hospitals.
Global budgets in Pennsylvania and Rural Emergency Hospital conversion both lifted margins. Independent Critical Access Hospitals still earn less than half the margin of system-owned ones. Toggle between the 2 views.
Key Strategic Takeaways
- Pennsylvania’s global budgets moved operating margins from -7.8% to -1.9% in year 1.
- 32 early Rural Emergency Hospital converters went from a -17.9% to a 7.4% median total margin.
- Independent Critical Access Hospitals average 2.6% margins against 7.0% for system-owned ones.
About this visual
Rural hospital margins before and after two federal payment models, and the gap between independent and system-owned hospitals.
How to read this
Figure 2: Operating and total margins before and after program participation, and by hospital ownership. Source: Chatterjee, Coe and Werner, Health Affairs 2025; UNC Sheps Center, March 2026; Whaley, Bartlett and Bai, JAMA Health Forum 2024
Related articles
Primary Data Source: Chatterjee, Coe and Werner, Health Affairs 2025; UNC Sheps Center, March 2026; Whaley, Bartlett and Bai, JAMA Health Forum 2024 · Author: Eli Brodsky