The State Can Only Fund What Applicants Bring
What I learned on the state side of the Rural Health Transformation Program, and a toolkit to help applicants plan past year 1.
What the state can and cannot do
From the outside, it looks like the state holds all the power. It wrote the plan CMS approved, it runs the competitions and it decides who gets funded.
Working on the state side, I learned how narrow that power is. The state chooses between the proposals in front of it. It cannot fund a partnership that was never formed, a service line nobody analyzed, or a plan that ends when the grant does. If the strongest idea for a community never reaches the application portal, it does not get funded.
Wording is not strategy
Most applicants put their energy into the proposal itself: matching the solicitation's language, hitting every scoring criterion, keeping the budget under the caps. That work matters, and it is part of what the toolkit below helps with.
It is not what makes a proposal transformational. The strategic questions come first. What does this community need over the next 5 years? Which gaps matter most? How do the funding streams, the state's initiatives and your own plans line up into something that is still running in year 6?
$50 billion over 5 years will transform rural health only if the proposals are transformational. Only applicants can make them that.
What drives transformation
The ingredients are local, and the state cannot supply them:
- Local data on who you serve and what is missing.
- Historical perspective: what has been tried, what worked, what closed and why.
- Local collaboration among the people who will carry the work.
- Judgment about what makes sense on the ground.
The state can fund all of this. It cannot create it.
Who has to be at the table
No single organization can build that strategy alone, which is why I am doing this work now.
- Providers, nonprofits, health systems and payer plans have to work together. Sustainability usually means someone pays for the service after the grant ends, and that conversation has to start before the application.
- Vendors need to innovate and also collaborate, with each other and with their customers, instead of competing for one-off contracts.
- Patients need to be heard, not just counted.
- The state needs metrics: leading indicators that show the work is on track and lagging indicators that show what will be true in year 5, not only in year 1.
That last point matters more than it looks. CMS recalculates each state's award every year, partly on reported progress. States need applicants who can show where the work is heading.
A toolkit for RHTP Application Strategy
I built the RHTP Application Toolkit so any applicant can work through these questions with their team.
How to Use the RHTP Application Toolkit
A 10-minute walkthrough from readiness to a submission-ready application.
11 slides on what the RHTP Application Toolkit covers, the 4 steps through it and a 4-week plan to get from idea to a submission-ready application. Built for rural hospitals, clinics, networks and their partners applying to state RHTP funding.
- Start with the 5-minute readiness assessment, as a team.
- Match each idea to a CMS use of funds and your state initiative before you write.
- Carry leading and lagging measures with baselines for every project.
- Show how the work lasts after the grant with a 5-year sustainability model.
What it helps you do:
- Take a 5-minute readiness assessment that shows where you stand.
- Match your ideas to the CMS uses of funds and your state's initiatives.
- Rank projects and build leading and lagging measures with baselines.
- Evaluate vendors and partners on 5-year cost, references and exit terms.
- Get ready before you apply with a checklist and an answer bank.
- Assess your community's needs with listed data sources and worksheets.
- See your state's award, the CMS caps in dollars and a CMS alignment test.
- Model 5 years of sustainability to show how the work stands without grant funds.
Open the free toolkit: RHTP Application Toolkit
Why a partner helps
The toolkit can help anyone think through these challenges. Ideas still take shape inside each organization, with its own history, people and constraints. It helps to have a partner you can rely on, who works alongside you and brings the right talent to the table as challenges come up.
That is the work Kamen Partners does. If you want to talk it through, I am happy to get on a call. The first conversation is on us. It can cover:
- Where you stand and what to fix first.
- Connections to people and resources who do the work you need, including ones that are not us.
- What has worked in other states.
- Planning and strategy for your application and for what comes after the award.
Book a 30-minute call with me. You can also send a note through the contact form or email ebrodsky@kamenpartners.net.
Sources
Food is Medicine Is in Most RHTP Plans. Few States Have Made It Medicine Yet.
Related Rural Health analysis: About 20 states put food into their RHTP plans, but only Delaware, Virginia, Kansas and Arkansas have clinical designs that look str…
RHTP: Most states are getting ready for value-based care. Few are paying for it yet.
Most states are spending their first year of Rural Health Transformation Program money getting rural providers ready for value-based…
RHTP and Health Information Exchanges
A rural patient can pass through a clinic, a critical access hospital and a referral center 2 hours away in the same week, and the r…